I haven't sat on them in person, but I have clicked on these two sofas like a million times. Sofa shopping is tough. So many of them are the wrong size and so many are way too expensive. This is my first sofa shopping experience (I am finally out of my futon years), so I want it to be perfect. Looks like Urban Barn has the best selection for the smartest price. I'll let my bum be the judge. Sofa testing starts after work!